You don't need a big budget to build a strong book of business. You need clarity, consistency, and real relationships. Jesse Hendon, Head of Life & Ancillary at Spark, and Brent Crawley, CEO at The Premier Agency, provided key insights on identifying, nurturing, and managing leads with focus on simplicity, relationships, and scalable business workflows during our Built for AEP 2027virtual kickoff.

Here's what agents need to know.

‍

Start simple, then scale

The biggest mistake agents make with their pipeline isn't a lack of tools, it's a lack of clarity. Too many agents think they need a CRM from day one, when in reality a pipeline can start with a spreadsheet or a notebook.

‍

‍

Here's how:

• ‍Define your pipeline clearly: A pipeline is not a tool. It's simply a list of the people who are not yet your customer and where they are in the journey to being a potential customer.‍
• Prioritize progress over perfection: Use the tools you’re familiar with until your growth demands more complex solutions.

‍

Own your zip code

Becoming the go-to Medicare resource in your community is one of the most reliable ways to build a sustainable pipeline. When someone turns 65, or a doctor's office needs to refer a patient, your name should be the first one that comes to mind.

How to get there:

• Search for the providers, pharmacies, and local organizations near you, the same way a consumer would search for you. Show up in person and build a real relationship with the people who run them.
• Focus on mom-and-pop pharmacies over national chains. Independent pharmacies want their customers to have someone to turn to for Medicare questions.
• Partner with senior centers, churches, libraries, and local organizations. These relationships take time to build, but they turn into long-term referral sources.
• Develop relationships with office managers and referral coordinators, not just providers. A lunch and learn with front office staff can open doors that a cold call never will.

Jesse validates this with a digital marketing win: "I created a business.google account so I’d be searchable. A chief medical officer at UCLA Medical Group called me after googling ‘Medicare broker Los Angeles.’ I answered first, solved their issue, and opened a new provider marketing opportunity."

‍

‍

Build your digital presence — it's free

A Google Business profile, Facebook page, Yelp listing, and even a TikTok account cost nothing to set up, and they make you searchable. When someone looks up "Medicare broker" near them, you want to be the name that shows up.

Where to start:

• Set up a Google Business profile and build reviews consistently. Search visibility is one of the most underused tools agents have.
• Post educational content on the platforms your clients are already using. It doesn't need to be polished. A short video explaining a Medicare basic can do more for your visibility than a slick, produced piece.
• Start a YouTube channel for Medicare 101 content. Consistency matters more than production value.

‍

Track what's actually working

Every flyer, event, postcard, or community partnership should be measurable. Instead of guessing which efforts are paying off, use QR codes and source tracking so you know exactly where your calls and appointments are coming from. That data lets you invest more in what's working and cut what isn't, and it gives you something concrete to show partners who want to see return on their sponsorship.

‍

Diversify your lead mix

A diversified lead mix keeps your pipeline resilient. Referral-only business is the gold standard, but most agents will want a mix of sources: consumer-initiated calls, live transfers, appointment setting, seminar leads, direct mail, and outbound dialing all have a place, depending on your goals and your agents' comfort level.

A few things to keep in mind:

• Consumer-initiated calls tend to bring lower incentivized traffic and higher intent.
• Direct mail can be effective, but timing matters.
• Manage your drop schedule so you're not overwhelmed in the first two weeks of AEP and quiet for the rest of it.
• If you outbound dial, make sure you have proper consent to stay compliant.

Whatever mix you choose, keep testing and keep sourcing. Don't rely on just one channel.

‍

Ask for referrals

Referrals are one of the highest-value, lowest-cost ways to grow. Ask for them directly from your existing clients, and make it easy: put a referral ask at the bottom of your emails, the way realtors do on their business cards.

Other ways to generate referral-driven leads? Run educational workshops and Medicare 101 sessions in your community. And keep an eye on where carriers are moving; if a plan is exiting your market, get in front of it. Reach out to local news, post on social media, and position yourself as the local expert who can explain what's changing. And don't forget to call your existing clients just to check in. A quick, no-agenda call keeps you top of mind and often surfaces referral opportunities naturally.

‍

‍

Prepare now, not in October

Preparation now means fewer headaches during AEP. A few things to knock out before October 1:

• Confirm your scope of appointment covers everything you want to sell, including ancillary products like hospital indemnity, short-term care, critical illness, Medicare Supplement, Part D, and Medicare Advantage.
• Submit marketing materials for carrier preapproval well before September 1. Don't wait until the last minute.
• Test your lead capture. Check that your web pages, CTAs, and QR codes all go where they're supposed to.
• Remember the compliance line: before October 1, keep every conversation educational. After October 1, you can discuss specific plans.

The bottom line is that none of this requires a big budget or complex technology. It requires showing up consistently, being the trusted resource in your community, and building relationships that create mutual value, not just transactions.

Start simple, track what works, and keep showing up. Your network is your net worth.

‍

‍